Customer Reviews

Discover what our valued customers have to say

Testimonials

Here’s What Our Clients Are Saying…

“We’ve had the pleasure of working with Natalie’s Custom Catering for several of our corporate events, and each experience has been nothing short of exceptional. From the initial planning stages to the final cleanup, Natalie and her team are professional, detail-oriented, and truly dedicated to making every event perfect.

Natalie goes above and beyond to create a fun and memorable atmosphere, and it really shows in the quality of the food and service. Everything is fresh, beautifully presented, and absolutely delicious. Personally, I can’t get enough of the sesame chicken - it’s my favorite! And whatever you do, don’t skip the cannolis - they’re the perfect sweet ending to an incredible meal.”

Grace Construction Customer

“We used Natalie’s Custom Catering for my baby shower and my son’s Baptism celebration. We could not have been happier with the food (taste and display) and service. We will definitely be using Natalie again for our next big celebration and will continue to recommend her company.”

Keri Romann Customer

“Thank you so much for doing the catering for our Grand Opening. The food and service were excellent and we have had many compliments from our guests on how superb it was. Your help, advice, and attention to detail really made the lead-up to the grand opening a breeze…thanks again for everything you’ve done for us. We will not hesitate in recommending Natalie’s Custom Catering.”

Navy Federal Credit Union Customer

“I needed a caterer for my niece’s bridal shower and was given Natalie’s name by a friend. The event turned out so lovely that I had no hesitation in hiring her for my daughter’s wedding. On both occasions, the food was fresh, creative, and exceptionally displayed. Her patience and expertise in creating an affordable, delicious, and quality menu took the worry out of planning such a momentous occasion. The staff is professional, reliable and Natalie herself is so easy to work with. Everyone at both my events was impressed with her food and the presentation. I wish I could keep her my secret but I know how difficult it is to find a quality caterer so I am willing to share.”

Monica Customer

“As former director of public events for the municipality of Magnolia, New Jersey, I arranged for food and beverage service for all kinds of events, from sit-down dinners to finger-food buffets. Natalie’s food was always fresh and well-prepared. The service - excellent, the pricing – competitive. I always received many compliments and would recommend Natalie’s Custom Catering wholeheartedly.”

Paula Bonamassa Councilwoman Borough of Magnolia

“…the food is fantastic and unique - not your typical catering fare. And the service is incredible! Our clients are always pleased; they know we care about them by the quality of food we serve. Natalie makes our company look good.”

Anthony F. Bruce, CPA Customer

“Natalie was a delight to work with for our wedding reception that included hors d’oeuvres and dinner for 150 guests. She made planning so easy, asking us our preferences and tastes and then coming up with suggestions that were right on the mark. She was so perceptive! As for the reception, she handled everything including linens, table decorations, and tableware. The set-up was flawless and the reception went off without a hitch. I heard guests rave about it all – the food, fresh and presented beautifully, and the service – attentive and fluid. We were more than satisfied with everything, even her prices – which were incredibly reasonable. Natalie is one of the best!”

Jerry and Peggy Buescher Customer

“Natalie called me out of the blue one day…about trying her catering service for our business food needs. I was very happy with our current catering service but agreed to try samples off her lunch menu that Natalie dropped off for us. Upon tasting her delicious offerings that were amazing and not overpowered with condiments or sauces was all I needed to switch our business food needs strictly to Natalie’s Custom Catering.

Whether she is catering an employee lunch, client lunch, or in-house executive staff dinner event for us, I can always depend upon her superior food cooked to perfection and beautifully presented. Our employees get excited when they find out Natalie is providing their meal. Her staff is most professional and is as easy to work with as Natalie. She makes my demanding job so much easier and it’s always refreshing to hear only great feedback.”

Denise Geraghty Executive Assistant to the President & CEO Corporate Synergies

“Over the past several years, I’ve had the pleasure of working with Natalie’s Custom Catering on events ranging from a buffet dinner for 40, to events for 450. From brunches, barbecues, and dinners, to in-homes, in-halls, and under tents - the food and service have always been excellent. Natalie is comfortable working within our budget and produces an occasion that is always special. I continue to recommend their services to friends and colleagues alike.”

Nancy Weber Oak Ridge Consultants, LLC

“We’ve not only been repeat clients of Natalie’s…but recommend her to anyone looking for a great caterer. Her customized lunches are a highly effective way to thank valued customers. Her menu options are plentiful and satisfy even the most critical of tastes. Considering the rave reviews we always get from her quality food and top-notch presentation, we think the investment is not only reasonable but well worth it. Natalie never disappoints. She makes putting together a luncheon easy, from detailed planning to her punctual, thorough setup. A wonderful company!”

Adam Weiner President of Adam Industrial

“Thank you for everything…to make our event at LEAP Academy successful! The lovely set-up you did and so many people coming back for seconds and thirds of lunch! We had many wonderful compliments on the food, and you and your team were great to work with as well. We appreciated your flexibility with menu selections and attention to detail in food preparation and presentation!”

Mary Susan Lead Dog

“In my capacity as 1st Vice-President and later as Chairman of Ways and Means, I often engaged Natalie’s Custom Catering for a variety of events (some as large as 200 guests), including holiday parties, luncheons, monthly meetings, and private parties. Natalie’s provided an extensive choice of menus, attentive, professional staff, and without exception, our guests always commented very favorably. They are truly a “caterer for all occasions.”

Carmela Paulson Trustee, The Haddon Fortnightly

Client Experiences

The Stories Behind Our Success

“Natalie made our party just PERFECT! From start to finish, working with Natalie was an absolute pleasure.

I found out about Natalie when I tasted her food at my friend’s party. I had never tasted such scrumptious food at a catered event. The quality and presentation of her food are as if she were cooking for a small dinner party. I’m not easily impressed when it comes to food…. I’m a foodie. Natalie’s menu options are amazing, and – not only is her food fresh, creative, and delicious – her presentation is stunning.

Before the party, Natalie worked with me to design the menu and helped me with logistics, such as linens, table placement, and serving ideas, some of which I hadn’t even thought of…her wisdom gained from her many years of experience was clear immediately.

Natalie fed 60 people in our home…handled everything with incredible calmness, grace, humor, professionalism, and efficiency. And they seemed to be everywhere all at once, so I couldn’t even sneak trying to help! They helped me with where to have our guests put presents, and they even put flowers in vases when people brought them. I was amazed. It left me free to enjoy time with our friends and family. Priceless.

After the party, they cleaned up so well that you couldn’t even tell they’d been there except for the yummy leftovers they had neatly packaged up and left in our fridge.

Natalie made our day the success that it was, and I can’t recommend her enough. I feel so lucky to have found her.”

Melissa Plotts

Customer